What it creates: A structured side-by-side analysis with comparison tables, pros/cons, and a clear recommendation.
When to Use This
- You’re evaluating options (vendors, technologies, strategies, tools)
- Stakeholders need a decision-support document with clear trade-offs
- You want a visual comparison that makes differences obvious
- You’ve discussed multiple options and need to organize the findings
What You Get
A Comparison Document typically includes:- Executive Summary - Quick overview of what’s being compared and the recommendation
- Comparison Criteria - The dimensions being evaluated
- Side-by-Side Table - Visual comparison matrix
- Detailed Analysis - Deeper look at each option per criterion
- Pros/Cons - Quick-reference lists for each option
- Recommendation - Which to choose and why (with caveats)
Example
Conversation context: You asked the AIs to compare three project management tools for your team, with follow-ups on pricing, integrations, and scalability. Generated Comparison excerpt:Comparison MatrixRecommendation: Linear for engineering-first teams under 200 people. Jira if enterprise compliance is non-negotiable. Notion only if your team is primarily non-technical.
Criterion Linear Jira Notion Setup Time Hours Days-Weeks Hours Learning Curve Low High Medium Dev Integration Excellent Excellent Limited Non-Tech Access Good Poor Excellent Price (50 users) $400/mo $750/mo $500/mo Scalability High Very High Medium
Tips for Best Results
- In your conversation, explicitly ask AIs to compare specific dimensions
- Use task assignment: “@Perplexity - find pricing details, @Claude - analyze strengths/weaknesses”
- Ask follow-up questions about deal-breakers and must-haves
- The more specific your evaluation criteria, the more useful the comparison
- Works well after assigning different AIs to research different options
Best AI Engine for This Type
GPT-5.2 - Produces clean, well-structured tables and logical comparison frameworks. Precise with criteria and consistent in evaluation. Claude - Good alternative when you need more contextual analysis around the comparison data.Related Articles
- Turn Any Conversation into a Document
- When to Generate a Master Document
- Generate a SWOT Analysis
- Generate a Competitive Analysis

